The Ottumwa Courier

AP Iowa

September 10, 2013

Iowa AG asks judge to ignore 'sunshine advisory'

IOWA CITY, Iowa (AP) — Attorney General Tom Miller's office is asking a judge to ignore its longstanding position that government settlement agreements are public records, saying it's irrelevant in a dispute over the University of Iowa's two-year delay in releasing such a document.

In a brief filed on behalf of the university Monday, assistant attorney general Jordan Esbrook urged Judge Douglas Russell to ignore Miller's 2004 "sunshine advisory" telling Iowans that settlements involving public agencies are never secret. University rules that say public records are released without consent of the subject are also "irrelevant," Esbrook wrote.

The office is defending the university against legal action by The Associated Press, which claims the university violated the Iowa Open Records Act in delaying access to a resignation agreement with surgeon John Chaloupka.

The AP requested the document and similar agreements in 2011. The university released six others but declined to release Chaloupka's, instead notifying his attorneys of the request and giving them time to file legal action to block its release. University lawyers had concluded the document was public, but nonetheless allowed the delay after Chaloupka opposed its release on grounds that judges found lacked merit.

A judge rejected Chaloupka's injunction request in 2012, ordering the university to release the document immediately. The university again refused, giving Chaloupka time to appeal. An appeals court upheld the judge's release order 3-0 in January, and it was made public in March.

The settlement showed Chaloupka was stripped of key duties after clashing with other doctors, but allowed to keep his $380,000 salary for one year.

While the AP prevailed in securing the release, the news cooperative is asking Russell to rule that the university violated the law and to award legal remedies, including an order requiring the university to pay its legal fees and assess a fine against the records custodian. It argues that officials ignored university rules, state law and Miller's sunshine advisory.

Text Only
AP Iowa
  • State urges action to avoid West Nile virus DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — The Iowa Department of Public Health says there have already been three reported cases of West Nile virus in the state, even though the disease usually is seen in early autumn. The agency says cases have been reported in Clay,

    July 31, 2014

  • Iowa official: Goat grazing plan is working STRAWBERRY POINT, Iowa (AP) — An Iowa government official says the state's plan to use goats to clear away vegetation is an initial success. Iowa Department of Natural Resources supervisor Mike Steuck tells KCRG-TV ( ) the 60 goa

    July 31, 2014

  • Commission wants former Iowa prosecutor punished WINTERSET, Iowa (AP) — A commission has recommended to the Iowa Supreme Court that a former prosecutor who beat a client that he'd had a sexual relationship with should be barred from practicing law for at least four years. The Des Moines Register sa

    July 31, 2014

  • New attractions planned for Hoover library in Iowa WEST BRANCH, Iowa (AP) — The Herbert Hoover Presidential Library and Museum is getting a temporary $600,000 exhibit that will include a simulation of a World War I trench. The Iowa City Press-Citizen reports ( ) the exhibit wi

    July 31, 2014

  • Hot air balloon brushes power line at Iowa event INDIANOLA, Iowa (AP) — A hot air balloon brushed a power line and caused an outage at the National Balloon Classic near Indianola. An event official, Bill Clemons, says the balloon was on the ground Tuesday night when it touched the wire and then dra

    July 30, 2014

  • Wilson Island State Recreation Area set to reopen COUNCIL BLUFFS, Iowa (AP) — A state recreation area near Council Bluffs is scheduled to reopen soon. The Iowa Department of Natural Resources says the Wilson Island State Recreation Area will open its gates Monday. Workers are currently adding fire r

    July 30, 2014

  • Iowa parents speak out against school changes DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — Students at Des Moines middle schools no longer have the option to take advanced English and science classes. The Des Moines Register reports ( ) Tuesday that some parents are concerned that top performer

    July 30, 2014

  • Iowa's first startup accelerator set to begin CEDAR RAPIDS, Iowa (AP) — Cedar Rapids is joining the expanding pool of U.S. cities that want to kick-start fledgling businesses. The Des Moines Register reports ( ) that the Iowa Startup Accelerator begins Monday and is the fi

    July 30, 2014

  • Cedar Rapids murder case now in judge's hands CEDAR RAPIDS, Iowa (AP) — A Linn County judge is considering the fate of a 20-year-old man accused of killing a former women's basketball standout from Cedar Rapids. Cedar Rapids television station KGAN says ( ) closing arguments

    July 30, 2014

  • Inspector had cited lauded Iowa nursing home WAVERLY, Iowa (AP) — A northeast Iowa nursing home was cited for unsanitary conditions in its kitchen seven weeks before it was lauded by the governor's office as among the best such facilities in the state, The Des Moines Register (

    July 29, 2014

AP National