The Ottumwa Courier

Education

January 10, 2013

‘Grade’ not based on student achievement

Education officials say recent grade is how states match policy group’s ideas

OTTUMWA — The state of Iowa may have received an F on a report card, but the grade only reflects how Iowa measures up to one group’s idea of good education policy.

“The danger is in not reading the report [carefully], thinking that this [describes] the state of education in Iowa,” said Art Sathoff, superintendent of Fairfield schools.

What these various grades from groups demonstrate, say Iowa officials, is how well a state or a school district is doing implementing the policies supported by that group.

“Any organization that’s out there is essentially going to try to promote their agenda, their [preferred] policies,” said Superintendent Russ Reiter of the Oskaloosa school district. “As superintendent of a school district, I have to [seek policies] that are going to be best for our students.”

Iowa Department of Education Director Jason Glass sent the Courier a statement echoing the sentiment.

“Report cards from advocacy groups are common, but they are not based on objective criteria — they are based on the political agendas of each particular group,” Glass wrote.

For example, Iowa was one of the states that made national news this week when StudentsFirst gave state government an “F” grade for its education policy.

StudentsFirst CEO and Founder Michelle Rhee was the controversial Washington figure known for firing hundreds of teachers during her tenure as head of the D.C. school district.

The group does have its own agenda — and they don’t deny that this is a grade based on whether their specific ideas have been implemented.

In Washington, some praised her policies, while others expressed grave concerns.

Sathoff said he’s concerned when media reports fail to mention  the grading criteria. It’s easy for the public to believe a national group said the quality of classroom education in Iowa is poor.

Another worry in southeast Iowa: How can a single series of policies be good for every state in the nation?

“Policies are going to vary based on the needs of that community,” said Reiter. “When you take a look at Des Moines, Sioux City ... other areas, compared to what we might need in Mahaska County, we all have our different problems that we face, our different needs.”

StudentsFirst policies, as with some other national “grade-giving” entities, are intended to good ideas to guide all states. Yet policy needs vary so much from district to district, Reiter said, it would be difficult to have an all-encompassing set of policies for a single state, “let alone the entire nation.”

He said he can’t imagine one set of specific policies that would fit 50 states.

“In a word: ludicrous,” said Reiter.

That’s not to say new policies of some sort wouldn’t be an improvement, the superintendents said. Iowa education news has said for more than a year that the state is working on new regulations designed to boost student achievement. But the odds that all of the new laws would match the suggestions of any one group appear to be pretty slim.

And a press release from StudentsFirst acknowledges that “nearly 90 percent of states received less than a ‘C’ on the [StudentsFirst] State Policy Report Card, and no state earned higher than a ‘B-.’”

“While we appreciate the pressure for improving education, each state’s context is unique,” Glass said. “In Iowa, we have crafted an education reform agenda that is the right fit for our state.”

In fact, said Reiter, maybe Iowa could grade various political action groups on how well their policy ideas fit students and teachers in Iowa — or in Oskaloosa.

Text Only
Education
  • Annual student art exhibition at the Indian Hills Community college OTTUMWA -- It's been a busy year in the art department at Indian Hills Community College and the students are ready to show off their work. The Annual Indian Hills Student Art Exhibition will open on Monday, April 28 at 7 p.m. with a public reception

    April 24, 2014

  • 15-minutes.png A change at Evans

    OTTUMWA — You can get kids to memorize facts. But teaching them to think can take more time. Educational leaders told the Ottumwa school board that the school year that begins 2014 will shift Evans Middle School students from 45-minute periods to 60-

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0418 OTT Agriculture Day color photo 2 -T -L -M Cardinal students celebrate Ag Day ELDON — Sometimes the best way to learn is to get out of the classroom and come face-to-face with things that you might not see every day. Students at Cardinal Elementary School got that chance Thursday during Ag Day. Every year, the Cardinal FFA and

    April 17, 2014 2 Photos

  • 0418 OTT Joe Tafta color photo -L -T -M Pursuing opportunities

    OTTUMWA — Joe Tafta follows the rules. The Simpson College junior hopes to be a U.S. marshal one day, so he’s careful about what he says and does. But not always. On the afternoon of April 1, Tafta says, he nearly got booted out of Dunn Library for m

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0417 OTT Earth day color photo 1 -T -M Cargill celebrates Earth Day by educating ALBIA — In honor of Earth Day on Tuesday, April 22, employees from Cargill Eddyville and Cargill Pork are visiting with students at Grant Elementary and Lincoln Center in Albia all this week. On Wednesday the Courier caught up with them as they went

    April 16, 2014 3 Photos

  • Carrying bookbags a balancing act OTTUMWA — Permission slips. Notes from teachers. School activity announcements, birthday invitations, report cards and homework to sign. Kids bring home a lot of stuff. But is it done fairly? The school board this week was asked by ranking members of

    April 16, 2014

  • Van Buren to share FFA with Harmony KEOSAUQUA — Van Buren Community School Board approved a recommendation from its administration to share the ag program with Harmony for the 2014-15 school year. The decision means that Van Buren students would travel to Harmony to receive ag instruct

    April 16, 2014

  • Where to play OTTUMWA — The Ottumwa Community School District wants to discuss moving to another athletic conference. Superintendent Davis Eidahl revealed that the district has been contacted by a smaller sports league, which has extended an invitation to join the

    April 15, 2014

  • 0416 OTT Ron Oswalt mug -T School board member resigns

    OTTUMWA — As this week's school board meeting came to a close, the president read a letter from one of the members. Board President Carol Mitchell read that fellow board member Ron Oswalt was announcing his resignation from the Ottumwa Board of Educa

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0410 OTT picture Bracelets -M -T Caring Kids

    OTTUMWA — Five fourth-graders didn't need grownups to show them it feels good to help others. They found out firsthand. "I wanted to do a project with the bracelets I make. And it's better to help people than to just do a random project," Kennedy Hug

    April 9, 2014 1 Photo

Obituaries
Record
Facebook
AP National