The Ottumwa Courier

Letters to the Editor

May 25, 2013

Damage caps at work

After several days of eyewitness testimony and evidence, a dedicated Iowa jury determined that the 32 mentally disabled men who were mistreaded, abused and from whom wages and government benefits were taken by Henry’s Turkey Service and its employees were entitled to an award of $7.5 million each. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission admitted that the award was “an appropriate and meaningful measure of the actual harm suffered” by these men.

These injured citizens will never receive the full and fair compensation determined reasonable by this jury because politicians arbitrarily decided that any injured person who pursues this kind of lawsuit, no matter how egregious the circumstances or how great the actual injury, should never receive more than $50,000 apiece. Hello “tort reform.”

The cap on damages in the Henry’s case, like all damage caps, overrules the will of the jury and imposes a one-size-fits-all damage cap decided by government, not the people for whom they serve. We all would do well to remember this case the next time you hear a group or politician argue that damages in lawsuits should be arbitrarily capped.

Who do you trust more to decide whether you have been wronged or mistreated and the amount of your damage, a jury of your peers or the government? “Tort reform” and damage caps are in reality just another way for government to take greater control of our lives while confiscating our constitutional rights to trial by jury of our fellow citizens.

Steven Gardner

Denefe, Gardner & Zingg, P.C.


Text Only
Letters to the Editor
  • Guardian angel rescued me On Dec. 18, I had been to Walmart and as always, I stopped by the Walmart gas station to fill my car up. I got out, pumped gas and I went to get in the car. I locked my keys in! So I had no choice but go see if the cashier could help me. And lo and b

    January 21, 2014

  • Why close plant when it could be cleaned up? Doe Run Company, south of St. Louis, is the third-largest lead smelter in the world and the only one in the western hemisphere. They provide for the lead demand in the U.S. and are a major contributor to the world market. On Dec. 31, they close due

    November 8, 2013

  • Collect lids and fight breast cancer The Southeast Iowa Affiliate of Susan G. Komen represents a 10-county area in its fight to end breast cancer. Your local affiliate is fighting for the screening and treatment programs that save lives and the research that brings us closer to a cure.

    November 8, 2013

  • Who are Tea Party Patriots? First and foremost, if you love God, you may be a Tea Party Patriot. Second, if you love this country we call the United States of America, you may be a Tea Party Patriot. Third, if you value freedom and all the people in our past and present who hav

    November 5, 2013

  • Branstad, please use the heart God gave you To Gov. Terry Branstad of Iowa: Please use the heart that God gave you. I am a senior citizen who is suffering needlessly because you have outlawed the only substance that can take away my horrible pain and discomfort. Pharmaceutical narcotics are in

    November 5, 2013

  • Library doing many great things for the community This past week was National Friends of the Library week. Here in Ottumwa, our public library would not be able to provide all the materials, resources and programming that it does without the support and assistance provided by our local Ottumwa Publ

    October 29, 2013

  • It's up to you to make Ottumwa great If a person were truly honest with themselves every time they bought something they would ask, "Am I getting my money's worth?" If the person selling would truly be honest with themselves they might ask, "Have I met or exceeded my customers' expectat

    October 29, 2013

  • Life too complex My knowledge of electronics stops with the on and off switch. I was persuaded to try a new-fangled cell phone. One of the more simple ones. It takes pictures, prints them, records day, date, time. Tells me where I am, where I should be, how I got the

    October 29, 2013

  • Think before voting We just had a Sara Palin type month. Now I hear that the Tea Party wants to take over the Republican Party. They think we have too much government. People out of work, not their problem. People living on the streets, they don't care. The Tea Party th

    October 29, 2013

  • Why micromanage Halloween? I take no pleasure in composing this letter. Once again another year, the Ottumwa police have made their draconian edict of setting the date and hours for beggars night. It's too bad that even a volunteer kids' holiday has fallen under the auspices o

    October 29, 2013

AP National