The Ottumwa Courier

Local News

September 20, 2012

Iowa Supreme Court reaches out

Tour an effort to help public understand how the state’s courts work

(Continued)

OTTUMWA —

 

Court is in session

A few hours later Cady was clad in his ceremonial robe, seated along with six fellow justices as they heard a pair of cases. One was a fight over a woman’s insurance benefits after a man incinerated himself, burning the family home (click here for details). It hinged on whether code changes after a similar case bar the claim. The second was an appeal of convictions in a drug case, centered on whether a warrantless search of a parolee’s property provided sufficient evidence for conviction (click here for details).

It didn’t take long before the justices started peppering attorneys with questions. A similar insurance case led the Legislature to change Iowa law, Justice David Wiggins said. Why is this case still an exception? Justice Thomas Waterman pointed to the change and asked about legislative intent.

Joseph Creen, the appellant’s attorney, said no legislative change can be construed to deprive his client of her benefits. The law bans benefits to the person who committed the act, not innocents, he said.

 “Insurance is to protect against accidents. This was an intentional act,” Waterman objected.

Justice Edward Mansfield asked about the impacts of the court’s ruling, speculating on whether a favorable ruling might open the door for people to burn their homes and later claim mental problems require them to be paid.

Pointed questions don’t necessarily indicate a leaning for the court. Ted Wallace, the attorney for American Family Insurance, was barely three sentences into his arguments before justices began interrupting.

As Wallace advanced his arguments, the focus turned to the Iowa Legislature. Wiggins said legislative changes often refer to specific cases when they are in response to rulings. This change had no such notation.

Wallace stuck to his stance that the Iowa Code changes apply. The fire was set with clear intent and, while the case may have been a suicide, it was a clear violation of the terms of the insurance policy.

“The facts still say that he knew what he was doing and there was an intent,” he said.

Christopher Kemp, the attorney for the appellant in the drug case, argued that an anonymous tip cannot be grounds for a warrantless search. He said that principle is absolute, even for a parolee who has signed an agreement allowing searches of person and property.

Kemp spoke less than 10 seconds before justices began questioning him. Mansfield asked to clarify the issue for the appeal. The woman was technically still serving her sentence, Waterman said. Justice Brent Appel pointed to an Illinois Supreme Court decision in a case he called almost identical. The court in that case concluded parole search agreements pass constitutional muster.

Kemp responded that, while the agreements allowing warrantless searches may not coerce people into abandoning rights, the prospect of release from prison is “certainly a motivating factor” for parolees.

Appel asked Assistant Attorney General Richard Bennett whether the state creates a “Catch-22” for parolees. If you grant permission for a search, you are searched. If you reject an informal request for a search, he said, officers grow suspicious and you get targeted for a search.

Bennett said the behavior of the people in the home went beyond the tip. They were evasive, he said, raising suspicions by their own actions as directly observed by officers.

Text Only
Local News
  • 0723 OTT Riverfront color photo -L -M Ideas flow at Riverfront Renaissance workshop OTTUMWA — Ideas flowed as freely as the river itself Tuesday evening as more than 100 Ottumwans shared their vision of what the riverfront can be.The Riverfront Renaissance design charrette, sponsored by the Ottumwa Regional Legacy Foundation, drew p

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Kids … not cash OTTUMWA — From a project that started with nothing, supporters created a top-notch education facility for at-risk youth. Someone in on the project from the beginning shared the story. Wapello County Supervisor Jerry Parker addressed a community advis

    July 22, 2014

  • Staying healthy during extreme heat OTTUMWA — After unusually cool temperatures last week, it may have been easy to forget how the heat of summer feels, but an incoming heat wave will quickly remind you. According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, heat is the No.

    July 22, 2014

  • Shooting ruled homicide OTTUMWA — The death of a man shot in Wapello County has been ruled a homicide. The Wapello County Sheriff’s Office on Monday received a 911 call of a shooting 4 miles southwest of Ottumwa. Deputies discovered Clinton Gus Leedom, 49, of Bloomfield, to

    July 22, 2014

  • 0723 OTT flood file photo Over $1 million to fight floods EDDYVILLE — It's not the way a town wants to get $1 million, but the damage suffered by Eddyville in recent floods has prompted the federal government to cut a check. Actually, it's Area 15 Regional Planning Commission, a community assistance agency

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Driver's license services temporarily suspended KEOSAUQUA — Van Buren County Treasurer’s Office has notified the Iowa Department of Transportation that it has suspended driver’s license services due to staffing issues in the county treasurer’s office. It is anticipated suspension of the services

    July 22, 2014

  • 0723 OTT Canoe Camp color photo -L -M -T Canoe Camp teaches water safety OTTUMWA — Six children at Pioneer Nature Area and Nature Center pond were making waves and getting wet as they flipped their canoes over in attempt to rescue each other. Since summertime and water activities go hand-in-hand, the goal of the activity

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0723 OTT Seth Techel mugshot -T Techel jury may begin deliberations Wednesday DAVENPORT — The jury in the third trial of a Wapello County man accused of murdering his wife may begin deliberations as early as Wednesday in Scott County, Davenport. The jury was excused mid-afternoon Tuesday while Judge Daniel Wilson, who continue

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Three appointed to Board of Adjustment OTTUMWA — Three new faces will appear on Wapello County Board of Adjustment, thanks to help from the county’s newspaper of record, the Ottumwa Courier. Four applicants applied for the positions and three were selected. New members include Marcia Week

    July 22, 2014

  • Slain woman's boyfriend: I didn't kill her DAVENPORT — A married man who had an affair with a slain Wapello County woman testified this morning that he did not kill her. Jason Tinnes, a jailer who worked with the late Lisa Caldwell Techel, said their affair ended shortly before she died. Tinn

    July 22, 2014

Photo reprints


Obituaries

Facebook