The Ottumwa Courier

Local News

December 25, 2013

Judge issues ruling in Pilcher murder case

OTTUMWA — A judge’s ruling will limit the prosecution’s ability to introduce some evidence in Robert Pilcher’s murder trial.

When a defendant has been convicted of prior crimes it naturally raises the question of whether those convictions can be brought into a new trial. Such convictions can be powerful influences on jurors in deciding whether the defendant committed the crime they are in court for.

But there’s another issue in play. In order for prosecutors to raise those convictions before the jury, they must be relevant to the case being heard. If they are not, the judge hearing the case is unlikely to allow it in.

Pilcher is accused of first degree murder in the 1974 death of Mary Jayne Jones. Jones was sexually assaulted and shot to death in a farmhouse west of Ottumwa. Authorities say DNA evidence ties him to the crime.

Prosecutors asked that evidence on Pilcher’s prior crimes be admitted during trial, a request the defense opposed. Pilcher has a long record of charges including burglary, theft and escape. But those don’t appear to be the cases prosecutors wanted to bring up.

Online court records show Judge Richard Meadows ruled the state cannot bring in “evidence relating to [Pilcher’s] prior commission of sexual assaults,” until the defense “opens the door to such evidence.”

In other words, the defense will have to use some caution in order to avoid giving the prosecutors reason to tell jurors about the prior cases.

Pilcher’s trial is currently set to begin Jan. 14, 2014.

1
Text Only
Local News
  • 0417 OTT Saving Center color photo -T -L -M Hedrick building has friends HEDRICK — The community wants a civic center, and they've been willing to work for it. "I'd say we have 15 to 25 volunteers each time," Tommy Smith of Hedrick said. "These are all good people." Smith was volunteering his services at the Easter Brunch

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Southern Iowa farmers preparing for planting OTTUMWA — Even though the winter seemed to linger like Iowa was going through an ice age and cold and wet weather has highlighted the early spring, farmers are starting to get out to their fields to put down fertilizer and get fields ready for planti

    April 16, 2014

  • 0417 OTT Camp Wapello fence photo -T -M -L Good fence irritates good neighbor DRAKESVILLE — For 82 years, Camp Wapello’s iconic entryway has welcomed people to peacefully coexist with nature. Now there’s a 400-foot barbed wire fence down the middle of the road. In February, Davis County Supervisors approved vacating of portion

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Carrying bookbags a balancing act OTTUMWA — Permission slips. Notes from teachers. School activity announcements, birthday invitations, report cards and homework to sign. Kids bring home a lot of stuff. But is it done fairly? The school board this week was asked by ranking members of

    April 16, 2014

  • Van Buren supervisors deny hog confinement permit application KEOSAUQUA — A proposed swine building in Chequest Township didn’t receive a seal of approval from Van Buren County Board of Supervisors. Supervisors voted Monday to recommend to the Department of Natural Resources (DNR) to deny the permit. Supervisor

    April 16, 2014

  • 0417 OTT Beth Howard bw cover -L -T -M 'Ms. American Pie' tours with her new book ELDON — With many hours and countless miles on her RV "The Beast," Eldon's pie lady, Beth Howard, is celebrating the release of her new book with a tour of southwestern states. Howard's second book, "Ms. American Pie: Buttery Good Pie Recipes and Bol

    April 16, 2014 2 Photos

  • Van Buren to share FFA with Harmony KEOSAUQUA — Van Buren Community School Board approved a recommendation from its administration to share the ag program with Harmony for the 2014-15 school year. The decision means that Van Buren students would travel to Harmony to receive ag instruct

    April 16, 2014

  • Attorney withdraws after client disappears OTTUMWA — Authorities are still looking for an Ottumwa man who didn’t show up for court proceedings. When they find him, he’ll need a new attorney. Jacob Nordyke faces charges of interference with official acts and possession of drug paraphernalia. H

    April 16, 2014

  • Waste Management wants to stay in Keosauqua KEOSAUQUA — Waste Management told the city of Keosauqua that it was not interested in ending the contract it has for solid waste and recycling services it provides to the city. A representative told the city mayor that it intends to fulfill the contr

    April 16, 2014

  • Road transfer under consideration KEOSAUQUA — Van Buren County Supervisors are considering an agreement to transfer the public road known as Iowa 98 from the state to the county. The route is approximately 1.81 miles, and the county will receive $2,310,000, according to the proposed

    April 16, 2014

Photo reprints


Obituaries

Facebook
E-edition