The Ottumwa Courier

Local News

January 30, 2014

Mistrial granted

OTTUMWA — After deliberating for five full days, the jury in the case of Robert “Gene” Pilcher concluded Thursday that more deliberations would not result in a verdict.

Pilcher is accused of the 1974 murder of Mary Jayne Jones, a 17-year-old girl who moved to Ottumwa from North Carolina just months before she was beaten and killed in a farmhouse a few miles west of Ottumwa.

The jury started deliberations Thursday, Jan. 23, at approximately 4 p.m. and informed Judge Richard Meadows, the presiding judge in the case, on Tuesday that they were not confident they would come to a verdict. Meadows then sent them back into deliberations, but at roughly 3 p.m. Thursday, the jury was brought into the courtroom and again stated they would not come to a verdict.

“We have reviewed all of the evidence and statements,” the head juror stated. “Some of the jurors have issues with some of the evidence and statements. We’ve done about everything we possibly can.”

After the jury stated they could not come to a unanimous decision if given more time, defense attorney Allan Cook requested a mistrial. The request was granted by Meadows with no objection from prosecuting attorney Denise Timmins.

“At this time, given the jury’s indications … we would move for a mistrial,” Cook said.

Once the motion for a mistrial was granted, Meadows sent the jury home for the last time before the attorneys and Meadows met in the judge’s chambers. He sincerely thanked them for all of their time and hard work throughout the trial, which started with jury selection on Jan. 14.

A retrial was requested by the prosecuting attorneys after the mistrial was granted, and a little after 4 p.m. the order for a retrial was filed as public record. The retrial has been scheduled for March 25 and is expected to last 10 days.

Text Only
Local News
  • Seasonal forecast Cool summer leading to cool fall? OTTUMWA — By late July, the average daytime high temperature starts to drop. What is normally the hottest part of the year is over. Averages are still in the mid-80s, and it certainly wouldn’t be out of the ordinary to see days in even the upper 90s.

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • Grant helps Hills keep students on track OTTUMWA — Thanks to a grant designed to improve graduation rates, Indian Hills Community College now has even more tools in its campuswide effort to help students with needs and give them the resources they need to stay in class. Indian Hills is one

    July 28, 2014

  • 0728 OTT ribs in eldon BBQ dinner with a hundred friends

    ELDON --- This year's Eldon Rib Cook-off was won by three BBQ chefs --- and about 150 hungry visitors. "I was down here last year, too," said Dwayne Yates from Floris, who was biting into his third smoked rib. "I never had a bad one yet." That's what

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • Mediacom: Rural cable consumers and companies mistreated OTTUMWA --- You may want to add just a racing channel, a court channel or a nature channel to your cable line up. Unfortunately, you'll probably have to buy a "bundle," which, ironically, is what it will cost you here in Wapello County. That's accord

    July 26, 2014

  • Alternate juror could not have convicted Techel based on evidence DAVENPORT — An alternate juror who was dismissed before Seth Techel, 23, of Agency was convicted of killing his wife and the non-consensual termination of a human pregnancy says the verdict could have been different if she had been in deliberations.D

    July 25, 2014

  • Overcome testing fear, get a good job OTTUMWA — It's not who you know, it's what you know. That's what City leaders say about getting a good paying job in Ottumwa. "It seems like in the last year we've had a real reduction in the number of individuals who've applied," said Joni Keith, hu

    July 25, 2014

  • Water Pollution Control Facility gets OK to upgrade OTTUMWA — An emergency Ottumwa City Council meeting resulted in spending $140,583 for the Water Pollution Control Facility. Friday afternoon, council members listened intently as Ottumwa Water Pollution Control Facility Superintendent Kam Reeves told

    July 25, 2014

  • Quincy Ave. project starts Aug. 4 OTTUMWA — Updates on the Quincy Avenue project was given to residents and businesses residing between Albia Road and Hwy. 34 on Thursday night at Ottumwa City Hall. About a dozen people attended the meeting where City Engineer Dan Sturm gave an updat

    July 25, 2014

  • Silence continues on fatal shooting OTTUMWA — Law enforcement is exercising its right to remain silent about a shooting death that occurred south of town this week. The Wapello County Sheriff's Office, which had responded to the shooting, said most information on the case would now com

    July 25, 2014

  • 0726 OTT cedar creek Gone in a flash

    BLOOMFIELD — Bob Parker got about as close to lightning as you can Friday morning, and came out of it without injury. A line of thunderstorms started moving through southeast Iowa in the early morning hours. Parker was heading to work at about 7 a.m.

    July 25, 2014 2 Photos

Photo reprints