The Ottumwa Courier

Local News

March 27, 2013

Ottumwa, others win suit against EPA

Court rules that EPA violated rule-making procedures, implementing regulations illegally

OTTUMWA — The Iowa League of Cities came out on top in a lawsuit filed against the EPA on behalf of a handful of municipalities, Ottumwa included.

The U.S. Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals sided with the ILC this week in its lawsuit against the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, upholding its challenges to EPA’s “rules” on sewage bypass and bacteria mixing zones.

“Basically, the court held that the EPA’s letters and positions on bacterial mixing zones with sewer treatment were illegal legislative rules that were made without observance of procedure required by law,” said Ottumwa City Administrator Joe Helfenberger. “The court vacated the letters and the unlawful rules that were announced in the letters.”

The battle began in 2010, when the League sought out the appellate court to review two letters the EPA sent to Sen. Chuck Grassley (one in June 2011, the other in September 2011), which the League argued “effectively set forth new regulatory requirements with respect to water treatment processes at municipally owned sewer systems,” according to court documents.

The League alleged that the EPA violated the Administrative Procedures Act after it implemented regulations without first “proceeding through the notice and comment procedures for agency rule-making.”

“These individuals averred that they indeed have taken the June 2011 letter at face value, interpreting it as establishing a new prohibition on bacteria mixing zones, one by which they must abide in the permit application process. We agree that private parties have ‘reasonably [been] led to believe that failure to conform will bring adverse consequences,’ which tends to make the document binding as a practical matter,” according to the League in court documents.

“We’re pleased with the outcome,” Helfenberger said. “It’s been a long, two-year process, but we got a good result.”

The city, however, will continue to follow its consent decree agreement with the Iowa Department of Natural Resources to complete its sewer separation project.

“The way the [EPA was] going about making administrative rules was being challenged, not the consent decree or anything to do with sewer separation per se,” he said. “It has to do with how they go about making new rules. They need to follow due process when they create new rules. It’s the ability for communities and the public to comment on them before they take effect. We need to preserve that. That’s the essence of democracy. What we fought for was the ability to have input before laws were created.”

Winning this lawsuit is “huge,” he said, because “the public wins when they’re able to see legislation and rules before they are actually put into effect.”

Helfenberger said the EPA did not follow due process when it created the two rules.

“They can certainly create new rules, but they have to follow due process when they create them,” he said.

The Iowa municipalities banded together under the Iowa League of Cities, each committing $25,000 toward the fight.

Alan Kemp, executive director of the League, said “this impacts not only cities in Iowa, but actually, it really has a nationwide impact.”

In “direct payment,” Ottumwa won’t see anything from the lawsuit, Kemp said.

“But is it likely that they may save in terms of the cost of regulation they might not have to follow? Yes,” he said. “That’s the reason Ottumwa and these cities saw this as an investment, not only with the current issue but it sends a shot across the bow of the EPA on other areas they need to be more cautious in how to choose to go about regulating.”

The decision resulted in three successes, Kemp said.

Right off the bat in 2010, the EPA had argued that the court didn’t even have the jurisdiction to hear the case. The court dismissed that argument.

Second, the court considered the two letters sent to Grassley, “and basically said the positions taken on these bacteria mixing zones and others were illegal legislative rules that they had made up without going through those rule-making processes required by law.”

Finally, the court ruled that the EPA didn’t even have the authority to regulate bypass and secondary treatment under the Clean Water Act.

“They can’t even go back and make rules on that, because the Clean Water Act doesn’t give them that authority,” Kemp said.

Those cities that may be in the design process based upon these rules may be able to take a second look at if they have to do what the EPA told them to, which would in turn save them money.

The EPA has 45 days to ask for a rehearing.

“We don’t know what they’ll do,” Kemp said.

Court documents

The court documents from the final decision in Iowa League of Cities v. EPA can be viewed online at

Text Only
Local News
  • Where do my taxes go? OTTUMWA — Wapello County Board certified its tax levy. But what does that mean? Based on budgets submitted by various levying authors, the Wapello County Auditor prepares and certifies the levy rates for the county. Budgets for each levy are based on

    July 30, 2014

  • OCSD releases elementary supplies list

    OTTUMWA — For years, parents of the students in Ottumwa's elementary schools have had to check to make sure the school supplies list they grabbed was the right one for their school. No more.

    July 30, 2014

  • Reducing runoff at the local level AGENCY — Pollution isn’t the first thing that comes to mind when you look out at a field of Iowa corn or soybeans, but there’s growing concern about what manages to get out of the fields and into the water. The same nutrients that benefit the crops c

    July 30, 2014

  • Supervisors wrestle with staffing woes KEOSAUQUA — Van Buren County Supervisor Chairman Bob Waugh says he wants county supervisors to help alleviate staffing problems within the county treasurer’s office. In May, supervisors opted not to replace a vacancy within the treasurer’s office. Va

    July 30, 2014

  • 0730 OTT Better Buildings -T -M Wildwood could be your home OTTUMWA — There was always one child per class who just adored school. If they went to Wildwood, they may soon be able to move in permanently. The Ottumwa board of education met Monday, where staff told them where the district stood as far as "facili

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • A changing roster -- for school board OTTUMWA — If the last time you saw your board of education was before Christmastime, the current school board might surprise you. Two members retired from the board: longtime educator Ron Oswalt stepped down, as did board president Carol Mitchell. Bo

    July 29, 2014

  • Iowa Lottery Lottery sales top $3 million mark

    OTTUMWA — Mother Nature may have thrown Iowans a brutal winter, but it didn’t stop them from venturing out to buy lottery tickets. On Tuesday, the Iowa Lottery confirmed that it had topped the $3 million mark in sales for the third consecutive year.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • halo-5-guardians-concept_wallpaper-1920x1080-53cf9b0098ea45ada37dc0f66bc174f5.jpg The Art of Kong

    OTTUMWA — The Mona Lisa. Whistler's Mother. Donkey Kong? Don't be so surprised, said Walter Day, that video games and the surrounding memorabilia are being considered art. The creativity and artistic vision required to create a poster, said the found

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • Slideshow: Truck overturns on roundabout

    July 28, 2014

  • 0729 OTT Picture veteran -T -M Veteran finally receives his medals OTTUMWA — A World War II injury may have saved the life of a U.S. Coast Guardsman from Iowa, but he lost friends and a box of military awards. Francis Hardy Harbour was born on Dec.16, 1919, in Drakesville. He joined the Coast Guard in 1941 as a mach

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

Photo reprints