The Ottumwa Courier

Local News

January 23, 2014

Closing arguments made

OTTUMWA — If the jurors missed something in this trial, the “summations” of the closing arguments could at least fill them in on what each side wants them to believe.

Robert Eugene Pilcher is on trial for the murder of Mary Jayne Jones, 17, in 1974.

For its closing argument in the trial Thursday, the defense offered a rebuttal of the state's closing argument.

"What the state is doing here, they are laying guess upon guess," said Allen Cook, the defense attorney.

But he doesn't refute Assistant Attorney General Denise Timmin's contention that Jones was shot. Nor that she died as a result of being shot, the first two findings necessary to convict this defendant of murder. He doesn't even argue, he said, against Timmin's closing statement saying the act was murder. He told the jury that it's clear there was a murder.

Not only that, he said, but it was certainly a first-degree murder. A brutal murder.

None of that has anything to do with his client, he said. And the prosecution has not shown any evidence that Pilcher committed the crime.

He could get into the farmhouse where the murder was committed? So could lots of people. There was a loaded gun at the farm, so Pilcher would have access to it? So would anyone.

But it was the new evidence, the DNA evidence, which reopened this cold case over the past five years.

DNA that shows what? asked Cook. That Pilcher had been to his cousin's house in the past? They already knew that; that he'd had sex on the bed? They knew that, too. His DNA on the blanket in multiple locations doesn't prove otherwise, but it doesn't prove murder, or even sex with the victim. The prosecutor's own evidence, Cook reminded jurors, shows there was DNA on that blanket from several males, including the homeowner, the defendant — and an unknown male contributor.

"Just so we're clear," said Cook. "An unknown male had sex on that bed."

The state implies, argued Cook, that the DNA was not even the most important part of their case.

"In 1974, they didn't even have enough evidence for probable cause to arrest my client," he said.

Closing arguments continue at 1 p.m. Thursday.

— News reporter Mark Newman is on Twitter @couriermark

1
Text Only
Local News
  • 0801 OTT Five Things logo -L T Five things to do in southeast Iowa OTTUMWA — Celebrate summer in a variety of ways and in several communities this weekend. Many towns are holding festivals, shows and events all centered around the summer theme, so head out while it's warm. 1. "Summer Shorts" is the Davis County Play

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0731 OTT Aviation plane -T -M Flying free OTTUMWA — The financial obstacle may have been removed if your career goal starts with learning to fly. "We have it set up for three terms, about nine months," said pilot and chief flight instructor Darren Graham at Indian Hills Community College. "

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • Supervisors discuss pipeline potential KEOSAUQUA — Van Buren County Supervisors received preliminary, general information on a new pipeline being proposed to carry oil from North Dakota through Iowa, including Van Buren County, then crossing into Illinois. The proposed Bakken Pipeline wou

    July 30, 2014

  • Fairfield stabbing suspects' trials separated FAIRFIELD — The three people accused of dragging a man into a Fairfield apartment before robbing and stabbing him have had a judge grant their requests to separate their trials. Dawn Dunn, Dustin Roll and Brett Hedblade are each charged with willful

    July 30, 2014

  • Local business donates grain rescue tube KEOSAUQUA — Stockport Elevator, owned by Roquette America, donated a grain rescue tube to Birmingham and Stockport Fire Departments. A training session was conducted Monday, led by Dale Ekdahl, a representative of Outstate Data, LLC, the device’s man

    July 30, 2014

  • Where do my taxes go? OTTUMWA — Wapello County Board certified its tax levy. But what does that mean? Based on budgets submitted by various levying authors, the Wapello County Auditor prepares and certifies the levy rates for the county. Budgets for each levy are based on

    July 30, 2014

  • OCSD releases elementary supplies list

    OTTUMWA — For years, parents of the students in Ottumwa's elementary schools have had to check to make sure the school supplies list they grabbed was the right one for their school. No more.

    July 30, 2014

  • Reducing runoff at the local level AGENCY — Pollution isn’t the first thing that comes to mind when you look out at a field of Iowa corn or soybeans, but there’s growing concern about what manages to get out of the fields and into the water. The same nutrients that benefit the crops c

    July 30, 2014

  • Supervisors wrestle with staffing woes KEOSAUQUA — Van Buren County Supervisor Chairman Bob Waugh says he wants county supervisors to help alleviate staffing problems within the county treasurer’s office. In May, supervisors opted not to replace a vacancy within the treasurer’s office. Va

    July 30, 2014

  • 0730 OTT Better Buildings -T -M Wildwood could be your home OTTUMWA — There was always one child per class who just adored school. If they went to Wildwood, they may soon be able to move in permanently. The Ottumwa board of education met Monday, where staff told them where the district stood as far as "facili

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

Photo reprints


Obituaries

Facebook