The Ottumwa Courier

Local News

January 23, 2014

Closing arguments made

OTTUMWA — If the jurors missed something in this trial, the “summations” of the closing arguments could at least fill them in on what each side wants them to believe.

Robert Eugene Pilcher is on trial for the murder of Mary Jayne Jones, 17, in 1974.

For its closing argument in the trial Thursday, the defense offered a rebuttal of the state's closing argument.

"What the state is doing here, they are laying guess upon guess," said Allen Cook, the defense attorney.

But he doesn't refute Assistant Attorney General Denise Timmin's contention that Jones was shot. Nor that she died as a result of being shot, the first two findings necessary to convict this defendant of murder. He doesn't even argue, he said, against Timmin's closing statement saying the act was murder. He told the jury that it's clear there was a murder.

Not only that, he said, but it was certainly a first-degree murder. A brutal murder.

None of that has anything to do with his client, he said. And the prosecution has not shown any evidence that Pilcher committed the crime.

He could get into the farmhouse where the murder was committed? So could lots of people. There was a loaded gun at the farm, so Pilcher would have access to it? So would anyone.

But it was the new evidence, the DNA evidence, which reopened this cold case over the past five years.

DNA that shows what? asked Cook. That Pilcher had been to his cousin's house in the past? They already knew that; that he'd had sex on the bed? They knew that, too. His DNA on the blanket in multiple locations doesn't prove otherwise, but it doesn't prove murder, or even sex with the victim. The prosecutor's own evidence, Cook reminded jurors, shows there was DNA on that blanket from several males, including the homeowner, the defendant — and an unknown male contributor.

"Just so we're clear," said Cook. "An unknown male had sex on that bed."

The state implies, argued Cook, that the DNA was not even the most important part of their case.

"In 1974, they didn't even have enough evidence for probable cause to arrest my client," he said.

Closing arguments continue at 1 p.m. Thursday.

— News reporter Mark Newman is on Twitter @couriermark

1
Text Only
Local News
  • City Council approves sale of properties OTTUMWA — On Tuesday the Ottumwa City Council met for the last regularly scheduled meeting of April. Included in the agenda for the evening were several dispositions of city owned property. Structures and land located at 519 W. Fourth St., 723 E. Mar

    April 15, 2014

  • Where to play OTTUMWA — The Ottumwa Community School District wants to discuss moving to another athletic conference. Superintendent Davis Eidahl revealed that the district has been contacted by a smaller sports league, which has extended an invitation to join the

    April 15, 2014

  • 0416 OTT Ron Oswalt mug -T School board member resigns OTTUMWA — As this week's school board meeting came to a close, the president read a letter from one of the members. Board President Carol Mitchell read that fellow board member Ron Oswalt was announcing his resignation from the Ottumwa Board of Educa

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Chronic wasting disease found in wild deer OTTUMWA — Since 2002, the Iowa Department of Natural Resources has collected more than 50,000 samples of captive and wild deer in Iowa in an effort to look for cases of chronic wasting disease. On April 9, they confirmed an infected wild deer had bee

    April 15, 2014

  • Good Shepherd Food Pantry making a difference BLAKESBURG — Good Shepherd Food Pantry in Blakesburg began its third full year of operation this month. Start-up funds included the South Central United Methodist Conference grant of $1,200 and a large cash donation from Hope Well Church in response

    April 15, 2014

  • Council approves sale to Historical Preservation Society BLAKESBURG — Blakesburg City Council on Monday approved sale of the museum property to Blakesburg Historical Preservation Society. The $4,000 bid submitted by BHPS was the only bid received. Terms of the bid include a clause that if at sometime the p

    April 15, 2014

  • County signs law enforcement agreement with Eddyville OTTUMWA — A law enforcement service contract between Wapello County and the city of Eddyville received supervisors' approval on Tuesday. Beginning July 1, Eddyville will pay the Wapello County Sheriff’s office $3,833 per month or $45,996 for law enfo

    April 15, 2014

  • 0415 OTT bbq photo, run small -T -M Where the smoke came wafting off the grill OTTUMWA — When the hobby they loved became a full-time job, Bubba-Q's owners had to put something they loved — barbecue competitions — on hold. "We haven't competed since 2011," said Sabrina Knapp, co-owner of Bubba-Q's restaurant in the Quincy Place

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • Armstrong sentenced in toddler beating OTTUMWA — Dustin Armstrong will spend 50 years in prison for the beating of an Ottumwa toddler last year. The assault took place almost exactly a year ago, when Ottumwa police went to 117 E. Woodland Ave. on April 22 and found Brayden Young, then 2,

    April 14, 2014

  • 0415 OTT Burger King fire photo color -T -M -L Fire closes Burger King indefinitely OTTUMWA — Workers at the Burger King in Ottumwa weren’t treated to an easy beginning to their Monday morning. They had to contact the Ottumwa Fire Department because a fire broke loose in the kitchen, effectively closing down the restaurant for the r

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

Photo reprints


Obituaries

Facebook
E-edition