The Ottumwa Courier

Local News

January 23, 2014

Attorneys: Use common sense

OTTUMWA — If the jurors missed something in this trial, the closing arguments could at least fill them in on what each side wants them to believe. They began their deliberations late Thursday afternoon.

Robert Eugene Pilcher is on trial for the murder of Mary Jayne Jones, 17, in 1974.

For its closing argument in the trial Thursday, the defense offered a rebuttal of the state's closing argument.

"What the state is doing here, they are laying guess upon guess," said Allen Cook, the lead defense attorney.

What he doesn't refute is Assistant Attorney General Denise Timmins' contention that Jones was shot. Nor that she died as a result of being shot, the first two findings necessary to convict Pilcher of murder. He doesn't even argue, he said, against Timmin's closing statement saying the act was murder.

Not only that, he told the jury, but it was certainly a first-degree murder. A brutal murder.

None of that has anything to do with his client, he said, because the state has not shown any evidence that Pilcher committed the crime. But why, asked Cook, do a state attorney and witness need to mention Pilcher was found in a men's shelter in 2012? Is it the need to have someone found guilty of this crime and it might be easier to convict a homeless guy no one cares about?

Sure, he could get into the farmhouse where the murder was committed, Cook acknowledged. So could lots of people. There was a loaded gun at the farm so Pilcher would have access to it? So would anyone who was there.

The new evidence, the DNA evidence, shows what? asked Cook. That Pilcher had been to his cousin's house in the past? They already knew that. That he'd had sex on the bed? They knew that, too. His DNA on the blanket in multiple locations doesn't prove murder or even that he had sex with the victim. The prosecutor's own evidence, Cook reminded jurors, shows there was DNA on that blanket from several males, including the homeowner, a visitor and the defendant — plus an "unknown male contributor," according to a report.

Text Only
Local News
  • 0802 OTT 73 Annual Golf Classic 73rd Annual Golf Classic OTTUMWA — There were a few records broken at the 73rd Annual Chamber Golf Classic Friday. "We had a record amount of people, and we also had a record amount of sponsors," said Tim Kurtz, executive director of the Ottumwa Area Chamber of Commerce. Fri

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Beach Task Force formation under consideration OTTUMWA — From the establishment of a Beach Task Force, to public hearings, to a discussion of open meetings rules and training, the Ottumwa City Council will have a full pate of items to digest during its meeting on Tuesday, Aug. 5. The council will

    August 1, 2014

  • Sewer works starts on Glenwood OTTUMWA — The 900 block of Glenwood Avenue will be closed to traffic starting Tuesday, Aug. 5. Boitnott Enterprises will be closing that block of Glenwood for a repair of a sewer lateral. Motorists should seek other routes around the work zone. Thi

    August 1, 2014

  • Emergency Management Coordinator leaving OTTUMWA — Wapello County Supervisors are hoping to compromise and assign a tax sale certificate to property owners within the city of Ottumwa. On Tuesday, the board will meet at 9:30 a.m. in the third-floor meeting room to discuss a variety of issues

    August 1, 2014

  • CAUTION: Drivers will notice delays on Quincy Ave. OTTUMWA — Beginning Monday, drivers on Quincy Avenue will start to notice the beginning of a major reconstruction project in South Ottumwa. The right lane of northbound traffic on Quincy Avenue, from the car wash located near the Quincy Place Mall's

    August 1, 2014

  • Transfer of West Nile Virus First reports of West Nile Virus coming in OTTUMWA — Three cases of West Nile Virus have already been reported in the state of Iowa this summer, but the timing isn't much out of the ordinary, local officials say. Current surveillance data shows one case each in Clay, Monona and Woodbury count

    August 1, 2014 2 Photos

  • WWI outbreak stranded Ottumwan in Paris

    OTTUMWA — Being stuck in Paris isn’t the worst thing in the world. The City of Light has always been a key stop for Americans traveling to Europe. It’s a city of culture, capitol of a world power. But Howell Cresswell, an Ottumwan in Paris, wanted no

    August 1, 2014

  • File.png Pleasant start to August

    OTTUMWA — Seasonal temperatures and a slight risk of rain herald the arrival of August in southeast Iowa.

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Graham's presentation A sweet history lesson OTTUMWA — In one of the most popular monthly presentations the Wapello County Historical Society has ever hosted, it was standing-room only to hear the history of Graham Milk and Ice Cream Company and try some of the popular product. A landmark in Ot

    July 31, 2014 3 Photos

  • Ready, set, shop! OTTUMWA — Iowa's government says businesses must participate in the Tax-Free Weekend this Friday and Saturday. Store manager Greg Martin isn't complaining. "It’ll be much busier [than typical weekends]. Back to school is the second busiest season nex

    July 31, 2014

Photo reprints


Obituaries

Facebook