The Ottumwa Courier

Local News

January 24, 2014

Jury needs more time

OTTUMWA — Parties interested in a 40-year-old murder case will have to wait a little longer to get an answer.

The jury deliberated a short time on Thursday, all day Friday and, with permission from the judge, will come back to continue searching for a verdict on Monday in the murder trial of Robert "Gene" Pilcher.

Before the jury was sent to deliberate, the trial saw both attorney teams saying this is an open-and-shut, "common sense" case that should lead to their desired verdict.

On the other hand, both attorneys also acknowledged there are some potentially complicating factors: Mainly, that a lot of time had passed. After 40 years, witnesses have died, the locations the jury heard about don’t exist and technology has changed. Both sides also claimed that if the trial took place in the '70s, it’d have been easier to win — for their side.

After Mary Jayne Jones was found murdered in 1974 in a Wapello County farmhouse close to Blakesburg, police interviewed potential suspects as well as people who could corroborate the statements of those suspects.

Most of the interviews were conducted in the presence of the young Special Agent Tim McDonald, who went on to become an assistant director of DCI. He is now retired, but in 1974, he was a field agent assigned to the murder investigation. He was a witness at the trial, speaking, in a sense, on behalf of the witnesses from the 1970s who could not be present in 2014. McDonald read the reports he made of the interviews.

During the trial, the defense showed a timeline that made Pilcher appear too busy to have committed the crime between noon and 3:30 p.m. on April 9, 1974. In fact, said the defense team, even without Pilcher’s statements, that is, just using the reports given by other people who had no reason to lie, he would not have been able to talk the girl into the car — without being seen — make it out to the farm, attack and violate her, brutally murder her and make it back to Ottumwa. All that with not an ounce of blood on him nor any strange behavior on his part as he did work for a charity and met a friend for coffee. As for DNA evidence, it showed what everyone knew: That Pilcher had been to his cousin's house in the past. So had other people. Charging Pilcher just doesn’t make sense, defense attorney Allen Cook said.

Text Only
Local News
  • File.png Pleasant start to August

    OTTUMWA — Seasonal temperatures and a slight risk of rain herald the arrival of August in southeast Iowa.

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Graham's presentation A sweet history lesson OTTUMWA — In one of the most popular monthly presentations the Wapello County Historical Society has ever hosted, it was standing-room only to hear the history of Graham Milk and Ice Cream Company and try some of the popular product. A landmark in Ot

    July 31, 2014 3 Photos

  • Ready, set, shop! OTTUMWA — Iowa's government says businesses must participate in the Tax-Free Weekend this Friday and Saturday. Store manager Greg Martin isn't complaining. "It’ll be much busier [than typical weekends]. Back to school is the second busiest season nex

    July 31, 2014

  • LCL scholarship recipients Supporting the health care future of the community OTTUMWA — For several area college students, Thursday afternoon was a chance to put names and faces with the thousands of scholarship dollars they have just received. The Ottumwa Regional Legacy Foundation hosted a reception to honor the 25 college s

    July 31, 2014 2 Photos

  • 0801 OTT DMV new building exterior -M Ottumwa's DMV station ready to move OTTUMWA — If you believe you'll need to visit the driver's license station next month, you may want to write this down: 2849 N. Court St., Suite B. That'll be the new address for the Iowa DMV's office, which is currently located across from the Fairf

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0801 OTT Five Things logo -L T Five things to do in southeast Iowa OTTUMWA — Celebrate summer in a variety of ways and in several communities this weekend. Many towns are holding festivals, shows and events all centered around the summer theme, so head out while it's warm. 1. "Summer Shorts" is the Davis County Play

    July 31, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0731 OTT Aviation plane -T -M Flying free OTTUMWA — The financial obstacle may have been removed if your career goal starts with learning to fly. "We have it set up for three terms, about nine months," said pilot and chief flight instructor Darren Graham at Indian Hills Community College. "

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • Supervisors discuss pipeline potential KEOSAUQUA — Van Buren County Supervisors received preliminary, general information on a new pipeline being proposed to carry oil from North Dakota through Iowa, including Van Buren County, then crossing into Illinois. The proposed Bakken Pipeline wou

    July 30, 2014

  • Fairfield stabbing suspects' trials separated FAIRFIELD — The three people accused of dragging a man into a Fairfield apartment before robbing and stabbing him have had a judge grant their requests to separate their trials. Dawn Dunn, Dustin Roll and Brett Hedblade are each charged with willful

    July 30, 2014

  • Local business donates grain rescue tube KEOSAUQUA — Stockport Elevator, owned by Roquette America, donated a grain rescue tube to Birmingham and Stockport Fire Departments. A training session was conducted Monday, led by Dale Ekdahl, a representative of Outstate Data, LLC, the device’s man

    July 30, 2014

Photo reprints