The Ottumwa Courier

Local News

January 24, 2014

Jury needs more time

OTTUMWA — Parties interested in a 40-year-old murder case will have to wait a little longer to get an answer.

The jury deliberated a short time on Thursday, all day Friday and, with permission from the judge, will come back to continue searching for a verdict on Monday in the murder trial of Robert "Gene" Pilcher.

Before the jury was sent to deliberate, the trial saw both attorney teams saying this is an open-and-shut, "common sense" case that should lead to their desired verdict.

On the other hand, both attorneys also acknowledged there are some potentially complicating factors: Mainly, that a lot of time had passed. After 40 years, witnesses have died, the locations the jury heard about don’t exist and technology has changed. Both sides also claimed that if the trial took place in the '70s, it’d have been easier to win — for their side.

After Mary Jayne Jones was found murdered in 1974 in a Wapello County farmhouse close to Blakesburg, police interviewed potential suspects as well as people who could corroborate the statements of those suspects.

Most of the interviews were conducted in the presence of the young Special Agent Tim McDonald, who went on to become an assistant director of DCI. He is now retired, but in 1974, he was a field agent assigned to the murder investigation. He was a witness at the trial, speaking, in a sense, on behalf of the witnesses from the 1970s who could not be present in 2014. McDonald read the reports he made of the interviews.

During the trial, the defense showed a timeline that made Pilcher appear too busy to have committed the crime between noon and 3:30 p.m. on April 9, 1974. In fact, said the defense team, even without Pilcher’s statements, that is, just using the reports given by other people who had no reason to lie, he would not have been able to talk the girl into the car — without being seen — make it out to the farm, attack and violate her, brutally murder her and make it back to Ottumwa. All that with not an ounce of blood on him nor any strange behavior on his part as he did work for a charity and met a friend for coffee. As for DNA evidence, it showed what everyone knew: That Pilcher had been to his cousin's house in the past. So had other people. Charging Pilcher just doesn’t make sense, defense attorney Allen Cook said.

Text Only
Local News
  • 0422 Eagle photo On a wing and a prayer

    LAKE RED ROCK — Protective gloves aren’t uncommon when dealing with a sick patient, though they’re not usually heavy, leather welder’s gloves. But, then, the patient usually doesn’t have toenails designed to puncture flesh. Or a sharp beak. Diane Mas

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0420 OTT Gothic house easter web-color photo American Gothic House celebrates Easter weekend Kids participate in an egg roll competition Saturday on the American Gothic House lawn in Eldon. Families were invited to come and participate in Easter-themed events and make crafts. They also had the opportunity to dress up and pose in front of the

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0422 OTT Egg hunt color photo -L On a roll this Easter ELDON — If you pulled up to the American Gothic House Center Saturday afternoon at moments before 1 p.m., you probably had to park halfway down the road. Cars filled the parking lot and spilled out onto the street as parents and kids from all over so

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • Ups and downs OTTUMWA — Iowa's governor and his lieutenant seemed thrilled with part of the employment news Friday. Gov. Terry Branstad's Twitter page said: "BREAKING: Iowa's employment reaches all-time high of 1,615,200." Iowa Workforce Development confirms the n

    April 18, 2014

  • Those who came before OTTUMWA — There is so much information on researching genealogy, beginners may not know where to start. But experts and knowledgeable amateurs will offer help as they gather for a free Family History Fair to share which websites are worthwhile and wh

    April 18, 2014

  • 0419 OTT Tree planting color photo -T -M -L Young Ottumwans show their green thumbs OTTUMWA — Several of Ottumwa’s cemeteries and parks were recipients of new trees this week as Ottumwa High School students and Eagle Scouts dedicated their time to planting dozens of trees around the city. Students from the OHS JROTC class were at Ot

    April 18, 2014 4 Photos

  • 0419 OTT Prayer Walk 2 bw photo -L -M -T On a journey OTTUMWA — The seven blocks through the center of Ottumwa took more than an hour and a half to walk as 25 people prayed and read Scripture to reflect on the events of Good Friday. Led by the Ottumwa Area Fellowship of Pastors, the walk began at First

    April 18, 2014 3 Photos

  • 0419 OTT drought map -L -T -M Drought weakens grip on Iowa OTTUMWA — Last weekend saw the first significant rains in quite some time for the Ottumwa area. How long? The last day with at least a half-inch of rain was back on Nov. 20. It was a welcome rain, arriving after the ground had thawed. That allowed at

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Eugene Clark STOCKPORT — Eugene Morris Clark, 90, of Stockport, died at 5:30 p.m. April 17, 2014, at Good Samaritan Health and Rehabilitation Center, Ottumwa. Graveside services will be at 11 a.m. Monday in Spencer Cemetery northeast of Stockport; Pastor Richard

    April 18, 2014

  • Civil War Round Table visited by baseball historian OTTUMWA — The Civil War Round Table was treated to a special guest Thursday night and a presentation about how baseball during the Civil War era helped shape Iowa as we know it. John Liepa, former history and political science professor at Des Moines

    April 18, 2014

Photo reprints


Obituaries

Facebook
E-edition